The Head Coaches from the Finger Lakes met at the end of the season and determined their awards for 2025.

The Finger Lakes Co-Players of the Year were Carson Lich (Pal-Mac) and Max Heieck in the East and Johnny Blair (Bloomfield-Honeoye) in the West. The attackmen of the Year were Johnny Blair (P-M West) and Max Heieck (Geneva-East), The midfielders of the year were Branden Thomas (Pal-Man-East) and  James Sprague (Midlakes-West). There were co-defensemen of the year in the West; Connor Tripp (Midlakes) and Michael Thomas (Bloomfield-Honeoye), while in the East, Carson Lich  (Pal-Mac) was named, The goalies of the year were Colton Rose (Livonia-Avon-Geneseo) in the East and Nick Falso (Gananda) in the West.

The Finger Lakes Coaches of the Year were John Hicks (Midlakes - West) and Joe Hill (Pal-Mac - East) and the assistant Coaches of the Year were, in the East, Tim Doyle (Pal-Mac) and John McGurk (Wayne) and in the West, Jordan Jarvis (Midlakes) and Dylan Joy (Bloomfield-Honeoye). The Persons of the Year were, in the West, Dan Riordan (Gananda) and in the East, Mark Pieroni (Wayne). 

See the Full Finger Lakes list here.