Penn Yan Reloads After Title

Program Outlook

Penn Yan enters the 2026 season in Class D following a 21–2 campaign that culminated in a New York State championship. The Mustangs combined consistent scoring with a strong defensive profile throughout the year, navigating a demanding postseason path.

Despite graduating five seniors, Penn Yan returns a large and accomplished core, positioning the program to remain among the top teams in Class D.

Coaching Continuity

Brian Hobart returns for his 23rd season as head coach, carrying a career record of 328–114 at Penn Yan. A Penn Yan alumnus, Hobart has overseen the program’s sustained success across multiple eras. His experience and continuity remain central as the Mustangs transition from another accomplished senior class while maintaining established standards.

Roster Composition

Penn Yan graduated five seniors, including contributors at midfield, defense, and goalie. That group included multiple All-Section and All-Tournament honorees. Even with those departures, the Mustangs bring back five rising seniors, 10 juniors, and six sophomores, creating a roster with both depth and varsity experience.

Returning Standouts

Several key contributors return after earning postseason recognition in 2025. Braden Fingar is back after a standout season with 65 goals and 25 assists, earning First Team All-Section and All-Tournament honors, and announcing his college plans with Towson. Tukker Fisher also returns following a 57-goal, 41-assist campaign that earned him Second Team All-Section and All-Tournament recognition. Greyson Hathway returns as well after earning First Team All-Section honors, anchoring the midfield with extensive faceoff experience. This returning trio forms the core of a group that accounted for much of last season’s production. They will be join with junior midfielder Mike Gigliotti who returns for his fourth year on the Varsity with a career 56g-19a record and junior defenseman Carter MacKerchar.

Statistical Overview

In 2025, Penn Yan scored 345 goals while allowing 151, averaging 15.0 goals per game and 6.6 goals against. The Mustangs return 240 goals, representing 70 percent of last season’s total, along with 114 assists, accounting for 65 percent of their assist production. Penn Yan recorded 15 wins by five or more goals and played seven games decided within five goals, including two one-goal wins, reflecting both scoring depth and the ability to manage close contests.

Games This Year

Penn Yan’s 2026 schedule again features a full slate of non-league games including matchups against opponents such as Thomas, Brighton, Canandaigua, Fairport, and West Genesee, providing a steady test as the Mustangs move through the season.

Season Focus

With championship experience, significant returning production, and long-standing coaching stability, Penn Yan enters the season focused on sustaining its level of play. The combination of proven leadership and roster depth gives the Mustangs a strong foundation as they begin the 2026 campaign.

Preseason stories are based on information from SportsFive.NET databases and coaches.

Stories are planned for each of the teams in Section V and will be released, a few at a time, between now and the start of the playing season. The stories will remain on the front page for about one week and then will be available in the NEWS archive. There will be links for all the published stories HERE and a link will also be available on each TEAM PAGE.